सं Samvidhan

Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023

Section 447

Power of High Court to transfer cases and appeals

Why this exists

Fair trials sometimes cannot happen where a case is originally filed, due to local bias, security concerns, publicity, or difficult legal questions needing a more experienced forum. This provision gives the High Court broad, carefully regulated power to move cases where justice truly requires it, with safeguards like notice, affidavits, and compensation for frivolous applications to prevent misuse of this powerful remedy. It corresponds to section 407 of the earlier CrPC.

How courts read it

Courts have emphasized that transfer of a criminal case is an exceptional remedy, not to be granted merely on vague apprehensions of bias; the applicant must show a reasonable apprehension that a fair trial is not possible in the current court, and the power is used sparingly to avoid encouraging parties to shop for a more favourable forum.

Common misconceptions
  • Myth: Anyone can ask the High Court to transfer their case for any reason at all, with no consequences.
    Fact: Transfer applications require a properly supported motion, sometimes a bond from the accused, and if the High Court finds the application frivolous or made to harass the other side, it can order the applicant to pay compensation.